Protocols & Policy · Prediction markets
A Senate-passed bill, a federal regulator's proposal and a Coinbase letter would each shape which bets on real-world events federally regulated exchanges may list, and none of them is law.
Washington is deciding, in three places at once, which bets on real-world events federally regulated exchanges may list. The Senate has passed a bill that would bar contracts on war, terrorism, assassination and a person's death. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), the federal derivatives regulator, has proposed to treat bets on real-world events as swaps, derivatives under its jurisdiction. A Coinbase letter dated Nov. 18 urges the agency to adopt that proposal quickly [1][6][8].
The contracts are event contracts, betting-style contracts that pay out if a stated event happens. None of the three efforts is law. The bill passed the Senate on Nov. 19 by voice vote, a vote taken without a recorded tally, and the Library of Congress action list shows no House action [3][4][5]. The CFTC text is a proposal whose comments closed Nov. 18 [6]. The Coinbase item is a comment, not a rule [8].
Yesterday's piece covers the CFTC's three lawsuits against Utah, Arkansas and Louisiana: Washington sues three states over who polices trading on real-world outcomes [9].
The bill, S. 4035, would add a subsection to the Commodity Exchange Act, the federal law that governs derivatives trading. A "registered entity," the bill's term for a venue that lists contracts or clears them, "shall not list for trading or accept for clearing" a contract that "expressly references" terrorism, assassination, war or "United States Armed Forces military operations," or one whose event "is reasonably expected to resolve principally based on a death of an individual" [1 §2]. The bar applies to contracts on an "excluded commodity" of the kind the Act defines as an occurrence beyond the parties' control that carries a financial, commercial or economic consequence [1 §2][6 n.10, p.66024].
The CFTC proposal, tracked as RIN 3038-AF82, would add a clause to the rule defining "swap" so that the definition covers "Event contracts, including those based on sports-, politics-, cultural, and weather-related events" [6 p.66033]. The agency says the statute already makes these contracts swaps and that its power to "further define" the term is "an independent legal basis" [6 p.66025]. A companion interim final rule, which took effect Oct. 19 while open for comment, says wagers a state-licensed sportsbook takes are not swaps [7].
Coinbase's letter "strongly supports the Proposal," and asks the CFTC to keep sports, politics, culture and weather as a non-exclusive list because "[a] closed list would provide less certainty" [8 pp.1, 7]. Coinbase owns a CFTC-registered exchange and a brokerage that offers event contracts nationwide [8 n.1, p.2].
The table sets the three side by side.
| Where | Stage | Date | What it would do |
|---|---|---|---|
| Senate bill S. 4035 | Passed the Senate by voice vote; no House action listed | Nov. 19, 2026 (floor log entry 6:47 p.m. ET) | Bar listing of contracts that expressly reference terrorism, assassination, war or U.S. military operations, or that resolve mainly on a death |
| CFTC proposal, RIN 3038-AF82 | Proposed rule; comments closed | Published Oct. 19; comments closed Nov. 18 | Add event contracts, with four example topics, to the swap definition |
| Coinbase letter | Comment dated Nov. 18; docket posting not confirmed | Nov. 18, 2026 | Adopt the proposal swiftly and keep its list of examples open-ended |
Table: Le Coin. Source: S. 4035 engrossed text and Senate floor log of Nov. 19; 91 FR 66022; Coinbase letter dated Nov. 18; opened 8:15 to 8:55 a.m. ET Nov. 20, 2026.
The bill changed on its way through. As introduced Mar. 10 by Sen. Adam Schiff, a California Democrat, it reached any contract that "involves, relates to, or references terrorism, assassination, war, or any similar activity," and any that "could otherwise be construed as correlating closely to an individual's death" [2 §2][4]. The passed text narrows both, adds Armed Forces operations and adds a rule of construction [1 §§2-3]. The floor log says the bill passed with a Schiff/Curtis amendment at 6:47 p.m. ET [3].
Today the Act gives the CFTC a power, not a prohibition: the agency "may determine" a contract is "contrary to the public interest" if it involves unlawful activity, terrorism, assassination, war, gaming or similar activity [6 p.66028]. The bill would turn part of that list into a flat bar on listing, and its rule of construction leaves the "permissibility" of the rest unchanged [1 §3].
Not everyone reads the swap definition the CFTC's way. The proposal itself says some courts and states have expressed the view that some, but not all, event contracts are swaps, because certain sports, political, cultural or weather events carry no "potential financial, economic, or commercial consequence" [6 p.66028]. The agency answers that its power to further define "swap" lets it decide which contracts qualify, and says it keeps authority to stay, meaning pause, the listing of a contract whose event has no economic consequence [6 pp.66028-66029].
The bill has its own limit: it reaches only contracts that "expressly" reference the listed subjects and says nothing about sports [1 §§2-3]. And Coinbase has a stake, as the owner of a registered exchange [8 n.1].
All three texts lean on one passage of the Commodity Exchange Act. The proposal quotes it to argue that contracts on non-financial events such as war and gaming fall inside the CFTC's reach [6 p.66028]. Coinbase's letter says it "expressly empowers the CFTC to regulate contracts based on 'terrorism,' 'assassination,' or 'gaming'" [8 p.3]. The bill's rule of construction points at the same passage [1 §3].
That makes the meeting point the one to watch. Coinbase wants an open-ended list of covered categories [8 p.1]; the proposal's examples name none of the subjects the bill would bar [6 p.66033][1 §2]; and the bill would close those subjects off by statute rather than by agency judgment. If the House takes up S. 4035, or the CFTC's final rule speaks to war and death contracts, the three efforts collide there. The proposal states no date for a final rule, and the Library of Congress action list saved at 8:15 a.m. ET Nov. 20 shows no House action [4][6].
[1] S. 4035, Engrossed in Senate, 119th Congress, 2d Session, "Passed the Senate November 19, 2026." https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s4035es/html/BILLS-119s4035es.htm (accessed 8:54 a.m. ET Nov. 20, 2026) [2] S. 4035, Introduced in Senate, Mar. 10, 2026. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s4035is/html/BILLS-119s4035is.htm (accessed 8:54 a.m. ET Nov. 20, 2026) [3] U.S. Senate Daily Press, floor log for Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026. https://www.dailypress.senate.gov/thursday-november-19-2026/ (accessed 8:55 a.m. ET Nov. 20, 2026) [4] Library of Congress, Congress.gov API, actions record for S. 4035 (saved copy; the congress.gov site pages returned HTTP 403). https://api.congress.gov/v3/bill/119/s/4035/actions?format=json (accessed 8:15 a.m. ET Nov. 20, 2026) [5] U.S. Senate, roll call vote menu, 119th Congress, 2d Session. https://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_lists/vote_menu_119_2.xml (accessed 8:55 a.m. ET Nov. 20, 2026) [6] CFTC, "Further Definition of 'Swap'-Inclusions," proposed rule, RIN 3038-AF82, 91 FR 66022 (Oct. 19, 2026), FR Doc. 2026-21377. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/full_text/text/2026/10/19/2026-21377.txt (accessed 8:54 a.m. ET Nov. 20, 2026) [7] CFTC, "Further Definition of 'Swap' To Exclude Casino-Style Gambling Products," interim final rule, RIN 3038-AF81, 91 FR 65969 (Oct. 19, 2026), FR Doc. 2026-21376. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/full_text/text/2026/10/19/2026-21376.txt (accessed 8:53 a.m. ET Nov. 20, 2026) [8] Coinbase Global, Inc., letter dated Nov. 18, 2026 to the CFTC Secretary, RIN 3038-AF82, 7 pages; the copy opened is on Coinbase's own asset host, and Le Coin did not open a regulations.gov or CFTC comment-file page. https://assets.ctfassets.net/sygt3q11s4a9/3lr2OLFe1qTrvXLl6IHzvx/0704c4e110b8335f9be8b8f24f9fd733/Coinbase_response_to_Further_Definition_of_Swap-Inclusions.pdf (accessed 8:53 a.m. ET Nov. 20, 2026) [9] Le Coin, "Washington sues three states over who polices trading on real-world outcomes." https://lecoin.news/protocols-policy/2026-11-19-cftc-states-turf/ (accessed 8:59 a.m. ET Nov. 20, 2026)
Holding the Corner.
Not financial advice.